Rosewater and Soda Bread – Marsha Mehran

Title: Rosewater and Soda Bread
Author: Marsha Mehran
ISBN: 081297249X
Pages: 304
Release Date: May 13, 2008
Genre: Contemporary Fiction
Rating: *** (out of 5)

I was initially going to give this book a meager two stars. I didn’t really like it and I felt like I didn’t understand a lot of it. The author didn’t seem to explain anything – who these characters were and what in the world they were doing in the middle of Ireland. I was confused, a little lost, and just didn’t enjoy the experience of reading the book. I was even more puzzled after I got on Amazon.com and saw that the average rating for the book was 4 stars – were other readers getting something that I wasn’t? I admit, by about ¼ of the way through the book, I was skimming. Heavily. Through that process, I might have missed some key explanatory details. But no, all became clear when the word “sequel” caught my eye in an Amazon.com review. Then I understood all and bumped up my rating a star, just to be fair.

Rosewater and Soda Bread is actually a sequel to Mehran’s earlier book, Pomegranate Soup. I obviously wasn’t aware of this when I put Rosewater and Soda Bread on my TBR list, but I really wish I had been. I feel like read the books in order would have explained so much, and I actually might have enjoyed Rosewater and Soda Bread.

However, I still had issues, despite the lack of understanding. The characters seem to be extremely flighty, especially the 16-year-old Layla, who is insisting on having sex with her long-term boyfriend. The thing is, even the boyfriend seems ambivalent about having sex at such a young age. And not once did either of her sisters say “At least wait until you are eighteen.” Not once did her sisters ask her why she was in such a hurry to become sexually active. I’m not trying to start a debate on sexually active teens, but if it were my little sister, I would be concerned. I would be realistic – there would be nothing I could do to stop her, but I would still raise it as an issue. Granted, there was a lot going on in the book, and the Layla issue did get pushed to the side for quite awhile. But that still bothered me.

There were also a lot of loose ends that weren’t tied up. I’m guessing that is because the author is planning on writing another sequel, but unfortunately, I won’t be reading it, or the prequel either. I feel like if I had read them in order, my experience would have been much more positive, but as it is, I think I’ll just stay away from this series.

Comments

  1. Thats exactly the problem I have with sequels. If I read them out of order, I dont feel like searching for the previous one just to make sense of the current. The only sequels I read are of romantic books. Especially by Nora Roberts. Each of her book can stand on it’s own.

  2. Yikes. I didn’t read your review because I have this book sitting in my tbr pile but I did check out your rating. I do have both books though so maybe for me it will be different.

  3. I always make sure a book isn’t part of a series before I even think about reading it because I’ve been “burned” too many times. Fantasticfiction.com lists a lot of author’s books in order even more comprehensible than some of the author’s websites.

    At least the cover is pretty lol!

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy:  I welcome comments and read each one I receive. If your comment needs a response, I will provide it in a timely manner, as I read every comment I receive. Please keep your comments civil and polite! I reserve the right to delete any comments that are rude or inappropriate. Because of spam, I have to moderate comments on old posts. Please be patient - I will approve your comment quickly.

Before the tag in the Genesis footer: !-- Quantcast Tag -->