Somebody Else’s Daughter – Elizabeth Brundage

Title: Somebody Else’s Daughter
Author: Elizabeth Brundage
ISBN: 0670019003
Pages: 352
Release Date: July 3, 2008
Genre: Contemporary Fiction
Review: TLC Book Tours
Rating: *** 1/2 (out of 5)

From the dust jacket:

Two young drifters, Nate and Cat – bottomed out on drugs and living on the margins of San Francisco – are forced by stress and circumstance to give up their infant daughter. Seventeen years later, Nate comes to the idyllic setting of the Berkshires to teach at the elite private Pioneer school – as his daughter’s teacher.

Willa Golding, ensconced in a magnificent country home with her parents, has never worried much about being adopted. But when the world she’s always trusted becomes a foreign place, she learns that her adoptive parents have not been totally honest with her – nor with others in their privileged circle.

Claire Squire is a visual artist struggling on the outskirts of her profession. It is a lucky break to get her troubled son, Teddy, a backdoor acceptance to Pioneer. But Teddy soon finds it’s a precarious place well disguised by preppy ties, plaid skirts, and activities designed to look good on college applications. He sees through it all – but that, too, threatens his slippery grasp on a better future.

Somebody Else’s Daughter is a collision of two very different fathers – biological and adopted; a woman whose independence and talent have led her to dead ends in life and love; and a villain whose intentions slowly unfold with the help, witting and unwitting, of all those around him. An electric, suspenseful tale of conflicted characters and the fractured landscape of the American psyche, it scratches the surface of the Berkshire dream – a place where people go to live their ideals, and to hide their secrets.

Somebody Else’s Daughter is a dark novel about the interaction of different families in Berkshire. The novel unfolds into a gripping tale of suspense, focusing on each of the characters. The book is narrated by different characters, allowing to reader to see the consequences of actions from multiple points of view. It is an effective method of storytelling, and one that Brundage uses well.

One of the most interesting thing about the novel is the way Brundage develops her characters. She establishes the basics of each character at the beginning of the novel and then spends the rest of it slowly building them up, layer by layer. By the end of the book, they seem to have developed their own lives, complete with damaged psyches. It’s an interesting method of character development that slowly draws the reader into the twists and turns of a person’s mind.
However, a consequence of this is the pace of the book – it is very slow. It takes a long time for the plot to become gripping and suspenseful.

The subject matter also makes the book difficult to read at times. Brundage deals with not one, but several weighty issues that could take up an entire novel on their own. AIDS, abuse, molestation, pornography, prostitution – and that’s just to name a few! Still, Brundage tackles each of these subjects well and should be commended on her ability to juggle these multiple weighty issues with dignity and due diligence.

Somebody Else’s Daughter is a novel that will appeal to people who enjoy character driven stories. If you can get through slow pace and heaviness of the novel, you will be rewarded with a well-written and expertly crafted novel that has a surprising ending you won’t see coming.

Now here’s a question for you: do you prefer novels with a fast-moving plot but relatively undeveloped characters or slower novels that take time to carefully build characters?

Thanks to Trish at TLC Book Tours and Elizabeth Brundage for sending me a copy of this great novel!

If you’re interested in learning more about this novel, check out the rest of the tour!

Monday, November 3rd: It’s All Fun & Games
Wednesday, November 5th: S. Krishna’s Books
Friday, November 7th: Mabel’s House
Wednesday, November 12th: Devourer of Books
Thursday, November 13th: All Thumbs Reviews
Friday, November 14th: Welcome to My Brain
Monday, November 17th: 1 More Chapter
Wednesday, November 19th: My New Reality
Friday, November 21st: Bloggin’ ‘Bout Books
Tuesday, November 25th: The Friendly Book Nook
Monday, December 1st: The 3 R’s: Reading, ‘Riting, and Randomness
Tuesday, December 2nd: Bookroom Reviews
Thursday, December 4th: Pieces of Me


  1. Good review as usual 🙂
    interesting plot.. and i would love to read it too!

  2. Sounds a bit like Jodi Picoult (whom I no longer can read since she always depresses me which then in turn puts me in a reading slump).

    For the most part, I don’t like a really fast moving plot where the characters can’t develop but I hate a slow moving plot too. I can finish a fast one quickly where as if it’s too slow, I’ve been known to give up on it. So I guess I like it more in the middle.

  3. I like both type of novels, depending on the mood I’m in.

  4. I like both also, but either way there has to be a ‘payoff’ at the end for me to want to read that writer again.

  5. Depends on the book and my mood. This one sounds interesting, all that heavy subject matter in one story. I’m curious how the author handles it. Great review!

    Diary of an Eccentric

  6. Sounds intriguing. I am not sure if I will read it or not because I am not into slow moving books (definitely more of a plot driven mystery person). But! I do enjoy good character books too. In a quandry!

  7. I’ve got this one sitting on my nightstand. I just checked out your rating. As to your question, I like both-it really depends on my mood when I pick up a book.

  8. I agree it is heavy but that doesn’t deter me at all.

    BTW, I linked your review with mine:

    Someone Else’s Daughter by Elizabeth Brundage

  9. I agree it is heavy but that doesn’t deter me at all.

    BTW, I linked your review with mine:

    Someone Else’s Daughter by Elizabeth Brundage


  1. […] November 5th: S. Krishna’s Books (this review will also appear as a guest post on Hey Lady! Whatcha […]

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy:  I welcome comments and read each one I receive. If your comment needs a response, I will provide it in a timely manner, as I read every comment I receive. Please keep your comments civil and polite! I reserve the right to delete any comments that are rude or inappropriate. Because of spam, I have to moderate comments on old posts. Please be patient - I will approve your comment quickly.

Before the tag in the Genesis footer: !-- Quantcast Tag -->