Haunting Bombay – Shilpa Agarwal

Title: Haunting Bombay
Author: Shilpa Agarwal
ISBN: 9781569475584
Pages: 368
Release Date: April 1, 2009
Publisher: Soho Press
Genre: Literary Fiction, Multicultural Fiction, Mystery
Source: Curled Up With a Good Book
Rating: 4.5 out of 5

Summary:

Pinky Mittal was just a baby when her mother died. Coincidentally, right at the same time, Pinky’s uncle’s baby daughter died under mysterious circumstances. Bereft, Pinky’s grandmother forced her son’s family to take Pinky in, though she was never fully accepted as a member of the family.

Thirteen years later, Pinky unleashes horror on the household with one simple action – she unbolts the door of the bathroom where the Mittal baby died. Until that point, the baby’s ghost had been locked in the bathroom every night, unable to do anything to those she blames for her death. But once Pinky lets her out, the Mittal family is forced to face some hard truths about their past and the way they presently live their lives, while Pinky tries to understand what really happened to the baby the night she died.

Review:

Shilpa Agarwal’s Haunting Bombay is an extremely unique novel about India. It’s difficult to categorize it – on one hand, it’s a masterpiece of multicultural fiction, giving the reader an eye into Indian culture and values. For example, the fact that Maji, Pinky’s grandmother, lives in a house with her son’s family is perfectly normal within Indian culture, though Agarwal never discusses it – it’s just an accepted fact of life. It manages to teach the reader without being blatant. Additionally, Agarwal manages to provide a social commentary throughout the novel – it’s sometimes difficult to pick up on, but she does an extraordinary job of revealing the injustices and prejudices that exist within Indian society. Though Haunting Bombay takes place in the 1960’s, the commentary is still relevant today. The ending of the novel is especially telling.

However, at its core, Haunting Bombay is also a ghost story. Agarwal does a wonderful job of keeping the reader on edge, unsure of what is going to come next. There is a level of unease that permeates this entire novel. The ghost story aspect of it is what really made it unique, and she handled it very gracefully. This entire novel is riddled with superstition, so including ghosts merely takes what is already present in the novel (and in Indian society) one step further. As a result, this does not come across as a fantasy novel, or one that includes magical realism. Agarwal handles the ghost story very realistically, and it is that much more compelling as a result.

Agarwal’s writing is also very beautiful in Haunting Bombay. It is difficult to tell that this is her first novel – her prose has the skill and confidence of a master of the craft. Her words have a wonderful rhythm; they make this book a real joy to read. Additionally, her style of adds to the theme of the novel. One of the central images in Haunting Bombay is water, both its life-giving and life threatening properties. The writing in this novel reminds me of smooth, calming, flowing water – it works incredibly well with the story.

Haunting Bombay is a wonderful work of literary fiction for anyone interested in learning about other cultures or in mysteries. This is a compulsively readable novel – once you pick it up, you shouldn’t plan on putting it down until the book is over.

Comments

  1. Great review. This looks wonderful. I can’t wait to read it.

  2. Great review. This looks wonderful. I can’t wait to read it.

  3. I’m torn about this one — love the other culture, other time aspect, love the literary aspect, not sure about the ghost part. Maybe I wouldn’t get that scared.

  4. I’m torn about this one — love the other culture, other time aspect, love the literary aspect, not sure about the ghost part. Maybe I wouldn’t get that scared.

  5. Beth F – Honestly, the ghost part of it isn’t really scary! I get spooked easily and didn’t have trouble with it.

  6. Beth F – Honestly, the ghost part of it isn’t really scary! I get spooked easily and didn’t have trouble with it.

  7. The combination of cultural and ghost story is very appealing. I love reading about other cultures and I enjoy a good ghost story every once in a while.

  8. The combination of cultural and ghost story is very appealing. I love reading about other cultures and I enjoy a good ghost story every once in a while.

  9. Wow! If the book is half as good as your review, I’ll love it. You’ve made me want to read this right now.

  10. Wow! If the book is half as good as your review, I’ll love it. You’ve made me want to read this right now.

  11. You make this one sound very appealing! I love books about other cultures and the ghost story in it intrigues me too. Enjoyed the reveiw.

  12. You make this one sound very appealing! I love books about other cultures and the ghost story in it intrigues me too. Enjoyed the reveiw.

  13. I have seen so many good reviews of this book. I’m definitely adding it to my wish list!

  14. I have seen so many good reviews of this book. I’m definitely adding it to my wish list!

  15. I have seen this everywhere but had no idea what it was about! Thanks for the wonderful review. It sounds really good and different too.

  16. I have seen this everywhere but had no idea what it was about! Thanks for the wonderful review. It sounds really good and different too.

  17. this is something i have been reading a lot about!! Liked your review! Someday i really will get this one!

  18. this is something i have been reading a lot about!! Liked your review! Someday i really will get this one!

  19. Great Review. I’m adding it to my TBR list.

  20. Great Review. I’m adding it to my TBR list.

  21. This isn’t one that I normally would have tried to read (though the cover is gorgeous) but after reading your review I think I’ll see if my library has a copy.

  22. This isn’t one that I normally would have tried to read (though the cover is gorgeous) but after reading your review I think I’ll see if my library has a copy.

  23. The multicultural fiction aspect is what I most enjoyed about this book, Agarwal made it all seem so effortless, the reader just WAS in India.

  24. The multicultural fiction aspect is what I most enjoyed about this book, Agarwal made it all seem so effortless, the reader just WAS in India.

  25. Oooh—sounds great! My husband was just in Mumbai on business, and I was thinking about digging back into some Indian literature, which I always seem to enjoy.

  26. Oooh—sounds great! My husband was just in Mumbai on business, and I was thinking about digging back into some Indian literature, which I always seem to enjoy.

Trackbacks

  1. […] Haunting Bombay (S. Krishna’s Books) […]

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy:  I welcome comments and read each one I receive. If your comment needs a response, I will provide it in a timely manner, as I read every comment I receive. Please keep your comments civil and polite! I reserve the right to delete any comments that are rude or inappropriate. Because of spam, I have to moderate comments on old posts. Please be patient - I will approve your comment quickly.

Before the tag in the Genesis footer: !-- Quantcast Tag -->