The Palace of Strange Girls – Sallie Day

Title: The Palace of Strange Girls
Author: Sallie Day
ISBN: 9780446545860
Pages: 352
Release Date: September 9, 2009
Publisher: Grand Central Publishing
Genre: Historical Fiction
Source: Publisher
Rating: 2.5 out of 5

From the publisher’s website:

Blackpool, England, 1959. The Singleton family is on holiday. For seven-year-old Beth, just out of the hospital, this means struggling to fill in her ‘I-Spy’ book and avoiding her mother Ruth’s eagle-eyed supervision. Her sixteen-year-old sister Helen, meanwhile, has befriended a waitress whose fun-loving ways hint at a life beyond Ruth’s strict rules.

But times are changing. As foreman of the local cotton mill, Ruth’s husband, Jack, is caught between unions and owners whose cost-cutting measures threaten an entire way of life. And his job isn’t the only thing at risk. When a letter arrives from Crete, a secret re-emerges from the rubble of Jack’s wartime past that could destroy his marriage.

As Helen is tempted outside the safe confines of her mother’s stern edicts with dramatic consequences, an unexpected encounter inspires Beth to forge her own path. Over the holiday week, all four Singletons must struggle to find their place in the shifting world of promenade amusements, illicit sex, and stilted afternoon teas in this touching and evocative novel.

The Palace of Strange Girls is a character driven novel that takes place over a week in Blackpool, England.  The Singleton family is tranquil on the surface, attentive to Beth and her needs, making sure that she recovers fully from her hospital stay.  However, underneath, there is much more going on than meets the eye,

The Palace of Strange Girls is a slow read, though it picks up once the reader gets to know the characters a bit better.  Since this is a character driven novel, it’s very important to connect with the people in it.  I really loved Beth.  She was sweet and young, wanting to live and be free when all her mother wanted to do was hold her back.  She was an incredibly well-written, layered character who was easy to love.

Unfortunately, I had trouble connecting with any of the other characters, and they are the real driving force of the story.  All of them were self-centered and difficult to like.  Ruth was controlling, materialistic, and way too status-obsessed, while Jack was preoccupied with himself and what he wanted, rather than considering how things impacted his family.  Helen was headstrong and unwilling to listen to anything her parents say.  While she was written as a very believable teenager, she still was frustrating and difficult to like.

Additionally, The Palace of Strange Girls had a tendency to jump in time without any warning for the reader.  One paragraph would be the present, and the next would be in the past – it was very confusing.  It would have been easier if there had been some sort of indication when the novel was moving to a flashback.

Had this been a novel about overcoming adversity or the characters becoming better people, it might have worked.  However, as it stands, I found it to be a slow novel that’s difficult to read because of the characters in it.  But if you’re interested in England in the 1950’s, you might still enjoy this book!

Comments

  1. I was thinking recently that you haven’t read (or at least not reviewed) a book you haven’t liked for quite a while! I guess it was bound to happen some time 🙂

  2. I was thinking recently that you haven’t read (or at least not reviewed) a book you haven’t liked for quite a while! I guess it was bound to happen some time 🙂

  3. I’m definitely fascinated by England in the 1950s, but sounds like I might be disappointed with this one! Still a gorgeous cover, though. Great review!

  4. I’m definitely fascinated by England in the 1950s, but sounds like I might be disappointed with this one! Still a gorgeous cover, though. Great review!

  5. Too bad it doesn’t live up to its potential.

  6. Too bad it doesn’t live up to its potential.

  7. I thought this book sounded good and I love the cover but after reading your review I am not sure I’d enjoy this book that much.

  8. I thought this book sounded good and I love the cover but after reading your review I am not sure I’d enjoy this book that much.

  9. Very honest review..

  10. Very honest review..

  11. I just stumbled on your blog this afternoon and loved it. Just thought I’d say hi!

  12. I just stumbled on your blog this afternoon and loved it. Just thought I’d say hi!

  13. Anonymous says:

    Hi! I know that this review is a few months old, but I stumbled across it as I was searching for reviews of The Palace of Strange Girls. I have to say I disagree with much of what you say – true, the characters aren’t all likeable, but that doesn’t mean that the book is bad. It means that the characters have more layers to them. Also, I don’t understand how you could think the time jumps were confusing – they were clearly marked by new chapter headings giving the time and place (for instance, “Imbros Gorge, Crete, 30 May 1941). The book had somewhat of an unpolished feel to it, but I hope your readers aren’t discouraged from reading it. It was intriging, had a nice holiday feeling to it, and gave an interesting insight to England in the 1950s.

  14. Anonymous says:

    Hi! I know that this review is a few months old, but I stumbled across it as I was searching for reviews of The Palace of Strange Girls. I have to say I disagree with much of what you say – true, the characters aren’t all likeable, but that doesn’t mean that the book is bad. It means that the characters have more layers to them. Also, I don’t understand how you could think the time jumps were confusing – they were clearly marked by new chapter headings giving the time and place (for instance, “Imbros Gorge, Crete, 30 May 1941). The book had somewhat of an unpolished feel to it, but I hope your readers aren’t discouraged from reading it. It was intriging, had a nice holiday feeling to it, and gave an interesting insight to England in the 1950s.

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy:  I welcome comments and read each one I receive. If your comment needs a response, I will provide it in a timely manner, as I read every comment I receive. Please keep your comments civil and polite! I reserve the right to delete any comments that are rude or inappropriate. Because of spam, I have to moderate comments on old posts. Please be patient - I will approve your comment quickly.

Before the tag in the Genesis footer: !-- Quantcast Tag -->