Some Girls Are – Courtney Summers

Title: Some Girls Are
Author: Courtney Summers
ISBN: 9780312573805
Pages: 256
Release Date: January 5, 2010
Publisher: St. Martin’s Griffin
Genre: Teen/YA
Source: Publisher
Rating: 4.5 out of 5

Summary:

Regina Afton is a member of the Fearsome Five, the most popular group of girls in school.  Her best friend Anna, is the leader of the group, and can be heartless, especially when it comes to bullying others.  However, Regina has always gone along with Anna’s wishes because she loves being popular.  However, everything changes for Regina one night, when Anna and the other girls turn on her.  Regina is forced to confront all the horrible things she’s done to everyone else, at the same time she becomes the object of bullying.

Review:

I have a confession:  when I started Some Girls Are, I wasn’t expecting very much.  I thought it would be a typical book about high schoolers and the drama that ensues when a once-popular girl suddenly loses her status at school.  After all, there have been plenty of YA books written on that topic.

However, Some Girls Are really surprised me – it’s about so much more than high school and teenage angst.  Regina was really an amazingly written character.  She seemed so real.  Summers did a wonderful job making her textured and layered – Regina does some horrible things in order to be popular.  There’s no one she can pass responsibility off to, no way to redeem her in her own eyes, or in the reader’s.  Yet, at the same time, she is so broken.  The things she has done, the emotional crimes that she has committed against others haunt her and have left Regina shattered.  It’s impossible to hate her because she is so real.

Courtney Summers tackles the subject of bullying in high school head on in Some Girls Are.  The things that Anna and Kara do to Regina are horrific.  More than once, I found myself in tears because it was so twisted and cruel.  At the same time, the reader is reminded that Regina has been awful to others.  Summers does an amazing job pushing and pulling on the reader’s emotions.  It makes this such a complicated, well-written book.

I highly recommend Some Girls Are.  I’m so glad I gave it a chance.  It’s a well written, gripping book about the power of forgiveness and the necessity of taking responsibility for what you’ve done.  It’s a powerful book that you shouldn’t miss if you’re interested in YA!

Comments

  1. I so want to read this. I love the movie “Mean Girls” and that’s what Some Girls Are reminded me of the first time I read about it. It looks like a good one to share with my girls, too.

    Great review, Swapna 🙂

  2. I so want to read this. I love the movie “Mean Girls” and that’s what Some Girls Are reminded me of the first time I read about it. It looks like a good one to share with my girls, too.

    Great review, Swapna 🙂

  3. Your review definitely makes the book sound much more powerful than I would have expected.

  4. Your review definitely makes the book sound much more powerful than I would have expected.

  5. I am getting this for the library I work at because all the reviews I read made it sound great! Thanks for your review and solidifying my reason for purchasing it! I cannot wait to read it.

  6. I am getting this for the library I work at because all the reviews I read made it sound great! Thanks for your review and solidifying my reason for purchasing it! I cannot wait to read it.

  7. You don’t even have to have a kid at the tween/teen age to know that this is a HUGE problem in schools. My kids go to a Catholic school, and the things that occur there make me sick to my stomach. Bravo to Summers for bringing it to top of mind. I will definitely be reading this one.

  8. You don’t even have to have a kid at the tween/teen age to know that this is a HUGE problem in schools. My kids go to a Catholic school, and the things that occur there make me sick to my stomach. Bravo to Summers for bringing it to top of mind. I will definitely be reading this one.

  9. This sounds absolutely amazing, and I’ve nothing but good things about it. I think I’m going to have to move it up the TBR pile.

    Brilliant review!

  10. This sounds absolutely amazing, and I’ve nothing but good things about it. I think I’m going to have to move it up the TBR pile.

    Brilliant review!

  11. Great review! I absolutely loved this book and I, too, am glad you gave this book a chance. It’s so deserving!

  12. Great review! I absolutely loved this book and I, too, am glad you gave this book a chance. It’s so deserving!

  13. Wow, it sounds like this book does a great job of tackling a tough topic. Thanks for the great review.

  14. Wow, it sounds like this book does a great job of tackling a tough topic. Thanks for the great review.

  15. When I first heard about this book, I kind of thought “meh, this has been done before” like you did, but I think you might have just won me over!

  16. When I first heard about this book, I kind of thought “meh, this has been done before” like you did, but I think you might have just won me over!

  17. Sounds really good. I’ll have to check it out. I wasn’t interested in read this, but now I want to give it a chance.

  18. Sounds really good. I’ll have to check it out. I wasn’t interested in read this, but now I want to give it a chance.

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy:  I welcome comments and read each one I receive. If your comment needs a response, I will provide it in a timely manner, as I read every comment I receive. Please keep your comments civil and polite! I reserve the right to delete any comments that are rude or inappropriate. Because of spam, I have to moderate comments on old posts. Please be patient - I will approve your comment quickly.

Before the tag in the Genesis footer: !-- Quantcast Tag -->