Unfinished: The Icing on the Cupcake – Jennifer Ross

Title: The Icing on the Cupcake: A Novel
Author: Jennifer Ross
Genre: Chick Lit
Source: Author

From the publisher’s website:

In Ansley Waller’s world of Southern belles and gentlemen, getting a diamond ring isn’t just important—it’s the ultimate goal. So when her fiancé, Parish, unceremoniously kicks her to the curb and cancels their upcoming wedding, Ansley is so ashamed that she decides to leave Dallas and make a fresh start. In a surprise move, she heads to New York City to live with her recently widowed grandmother, Vivian, whom she’s never met. In turn, Vivian gives Ansley a no-nonsense ultimatum: Rather than wallow in misery, either get a job or go home.

The Waller women have a tradition of baking their way out of sorrow. So Ansley mixes batch after batch of creative cupcakes—Black Bottom Heartache, Moving Blues Banana Caramel, Tres Leches Made Small. Before long, she’s opening up her own cupcake shop and even trying her hand at dating. But the ways of Manhattan’s eligible bachelors are altogether different from their Southern counterparts, and Ansley’s nearly fail-safe tactics fall flat. And worse, someone’s got a half-baked scheme to sabotage Ansley’s new life. It’ll take a cup of courage and a dash of Southern charm, plus a few secret ingredients, if Ansley hopes to pull off her recipe for success.

Why I abandoned this book:

I gave up on The Icing on the Cupcake about 75 pages in.  The main character, Ansley, was very unlikeable, though that was purposeful – I assume the rest of the book was about her “redemption.”  She vacillated heavily between being a horrible person and resolving that she wanted to be a better person.  It just seemed strange that she’d have such drastic turnarounds on what seemed like a whim.  Additionally, the book could have used some tighter editing.  It seemed like a cute story, and may have turned around had I stuck with it, but I just didn’t care enough about the character to see her through

As a side note, the book does contain a lot of great cupcake recipes and tips on baking which I found very interesting.

A quick look at reviews:

Amazon.com has 8 customer reviews, 7 of which are five star, and 1 is four star, so they definitely disagree with me.  LibraryThing has just one review, at two stars, and the reviewer seems to agree with me about the editing issues.  There are 12 ratings on GoodReads, with an average of 3.92 stars.  As far as blog reviews go, Booking Mama enjoyed the book, so make sure to check out her review.

I borrowed this format for reviewing unfinished books from Beth Fish Reads.

Comments

  1. When you don’t finish a book, I stand up and take notice. There have been a number of times when I probably should have, but I always feel like I owe it to somebody to finish it. The cupcake recipes sound good though!

  2. When you don’t finish a book, I stand up and take notice. There have been a number of times when I probably should have, but I always feel like I owe it to somebody to finish it. The cupcake recipes sound good though!

  3. This book would probably be hit or miss for me too. I probably wouldn’t care much at all about the main character’s loves woes, but the bit about the cupcakes would draw me in. I love me some cupcakes and would probably read the book for that part alone. I think I might give this one a look for the recipes alone, but I don’t think I will be reading the book in its entirety. Thanks for the insightful review!

  4. This book would probably be hit or miss for me too. I probably wouldn’t care much at all about the main character’s loves woes, but the bit about the cupcakes would draw me in. I love me some cupcakes and would probably read the book for that part alone. I think I might give this one a look for the recipes alone, but I don’t think I will be reading the book in its entirety. Thanks for the insightful review!

  5. I appreciate your honest review. Sometimes a book is not for you but another person may love it.

  6. I appreciate your honest review. Sometimes a book is not for you but another person may love it.

  7. I might check this one out of the library just for the recipes. Life’s too short to read what doesn’t interest you. (Thanks for the link.)

  8. I might check this one out of the library just for the recipes. Life’s too short to read what doesn’t interest you. (Thanks for the link.)

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy:  I welcome comments and read each one I receive. If your comment needs a response, I will provide it in a timely manner, as I read every comment I receive. Please keep your comments civil and polite! I reserve the right to delete any comments that are rude or inappropriate. Because of spam, I have to moderate comments on old posts. Please be patient - I will approve your comment quickly.

Before the tag in the Genesis footer: !-- Quantcast Tag -->