Book Review: Heresy – S.J. Parris

Title: Heresy
Author: S.J. Parris
ISBN: 9780385531283
Pages: 448
Release Date: February 23, 2010
Publisher: Doubleday
Genre: Historical Fiction, Mystery
Source: Publisher
Rating: 3 out of 5

Summary:

The year is 1583 and Giordano Bruno is a former Italian monk who was excommunicated by the Catholic Church.  He traveled across Europe until he finally ended up in England, a spy for Sir Francis Walsingham under Queen Elizabeth I.  Under Walsingham’s direction, Bruno travels to Oxford in order to uncover treasonous Catholics plotting against the queen.  But what he discovers in Oxford shocks him to the core and sets him off on a quest to discover a murderer.

Review:

Heresy is an interesting novel, made all the more fascinating due to the fact that it’s based on a real person.  Giordano Bruno was an actual former monk who was running from the Inquisition and made friends in high places along the way.  He may have been a spy for Francis Walsingham, but what is definitely known is that he was a humanist, a poet, and a philosopher.

Parris does an incredible job evoking the atmosphere of Oxford in the late sixteenth century.  Her descriptions are incredibly detailed; she clearly undertook a lot of research in order to get her facts just right.  It really pays off – this novel is not just a casual read.  Instead, it immerses the reader fully in the time period, the vivid descriptions making them feel as if they are actually there with Bruno.

The depiction of Catholic versus Protestant in this novel is also interesting.  Parris gives Oxford an atmosphere rich with religious tension.  It is clear that there is a lot going on beneath the surface, that these religious battles are tearing the country apart.  It gives the book extra depth and makes it wonderful for anyone interested in the fights between Protestant and Catholic.

The mystery, however, wasn’t as gripping as I would have hoped.  There was little urgency to the novel; it had a meandering pace that wasn’t suited well to a book about murder.  I didn’t feel like there was anything drawing me back to the book, to make me continue reading it.  As a result, it took much longer than it should have to get through and I found my attention wandering more than once.  It just moved much too slowly for my tastes.

Despite its flaws, Heresy is a clever and interesting book.  Parris has created an intriguing protagonist with Giordano Bruno.  I’ll definitely plan on picking up any future books she writes about him.

Comments

  1. I have this book, but put it aside as I did not think I would enjoy it. Sorry it was not a great experience for you either.

  2. I have this book, but put it aside as I did not think I would enjoy it. Sorry it was not a great experience for you either.

  3. I started out saying, Wow! I have to have this book — what a great premise. I ended up saying, well, I might give it a try, but not any time soon. Shoot.

  4. I started out saying, Wow! I have to have this book — what a great premise. I ended up saying, well, I might give it a try, but not any time soon. Shoot.

  5. I was intrigued when you said it was based on a true story – too bad the story meanders so much.

  6. I was intrigued when you said it was based on a true story – too bad the story meanders so much.

  7. In my opinion, this book title and author name sounds way too much like CJ Sansom’s series that takes place in Tudor England. So I’ve always thought of it as being derivative, and I’m not sure it’s one I’ll read.

  8. In my opinion, this book title and author name sounds way too much like CJ Sansom’s series that takes place in Tudor England. So I’ve always thought of it as being derivative, and I’m not sure it’s one I’ll read.

  9. I have an ARC of this and plan on reading it later this year – I thought it would be interesting to read something a little different than the usual Tudor stuff. There is a second book planned for release next year called Prophecy.

  10. I have an ARC of this and plan on reading it later this year – I thought it would be interesting to read something a little different than the usual Tudor stuff. There is a second book planned for release next year called Prophecy.

  11. I am not sure this one would be for me. I like the fact that it’s based on history, but the fact that the mystery is not really well constructed would probably put me off. I am really glad to have read this review though, as I had been on the fence about buying this one, and now I am not! Thanks!

  12. I am not sure this one would be for me. I like the fact that it’s based on history, but the fact that the mystery is not really well constructed would probably put me off. I am really glad to have read this review though, as I had been on the fence about buying this one, and now I am not! Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy:  I welcome comments and read each one I receive. If your comment needs a response, I will provide it in a timely manner, as I read every comment I receive. Please keep your comments civil and polite! I reserve the right to delete any comments that are rude or inappropriate. Because of spam, I have to moderate comments on old posts. Please be patient - I will approve your comment quickly.

Before the tag in the Genesis footer: !-- Quantcast Tag -->