Book Review: I Remember You – Harriet Evans

Title: I Remember You
Author: Harriet Evans
ISBN: 9781439182000
Pages: 464
Release Date: June 15, 2010
Publisher: Downtown Press
Genre: Chick Lit
Source: Publicist
Rating: 3.5 out of 5

Summary:

Tess and Adam have been best friends almost since birth.  Growing up in the small town of Langford, they were inseparable.  Everyone assumed they would end up together.  However, things didn’t turn out as people expected – after his mother’s death, Adam stayed in Langford rather than going off to college.  Tess fled Langford and moved to London.

Twelve years later, Tess has accepted a job at Langford College.  She returns home to find some things very different and some, like Adam, exactly the same.  She must face old feelings and ghosts from the past as she struggles with what she wants and understands what she needs out of her life.

Review:

I was a big fan of Harriet Evans’ The Love of Her Life and A Hopeless Romantic, but disappointed by Going Home, so I wasn’t sure what to expect with I Remember You.  After having read it, I’m still not sure what to think – I did like it, but have mixed feelings on it.  Some aspects I really enjoyed, but others didn’t work for me.

I really did like the character of Tess.  She was a bit lost at the beginning of the novel, but she was sweet and genuine.  She also had a healthy sense of humor.  She made a great main character for this book, as I was rooting for her from beginning to end.  The secondary characters from Langford were also well-written and a lot of fun.  Evans did a wonderful job infusing life into this small town and making it appealing.  At the same time, though, it’s easy to see why Tess is reluctant to be back there.

Evans also made an important debate one of the centerpieces of the novel, one I’m sure is currently rampaging through the English countryside.  How do towns that are mostly dependent on tourist income – Jane Austen slept here, and the like – maintain their character without becoming tourist traps?  At the same time, how do they cater to their residents who must grapple with their towns being taken over and balance convenience (having a supermarket, which would turn off tourists) with their economic livelihood?  It’s an interesting dilemma, and very easy to see both sides.

While I did like the main character and many of the secondary characters, I didn’t like two very important people in the novel – Adam and Francesca.  Francesca is a woman who just moved to town, escaping from London, and becomes Tess’s roommate.  She and Adam quickly involve themselves in a relationship.  It’s strange because I couldn’t understand why Tess was friends with her.  They often fought and Francesca seemed mean a lot of the time.  Adam was the same way – he was unnecessarily cruel way too often.  I understand he and Tess have a history, but I couldn’t understand why he was such a mean person.  He definitely changes over the course of the novel, but I never shook that initial impression of him.

I Remember You is also a bit too long.  There was really no need for this book to be over 300 or so pages.  As a result, it really drags towards the end when the reader can see exactly where everything is heading, but it takes about 100 pages to get there.  It’s a minor quibble, but an important one.

All in all, while I liked I Remember You, I can’t say I truly enjoyed it.  There were parts that were really interesting, and parts that just weren’t.  It seemed as if Evans was trying to do a little too much with this book, and in this case, less would have been better.  Despite my mixed feelings on this book, I will make sure to read her next one!

Affiliate Links:

Buy this book from Powell’s Books
Buy this book from Amazon.com

Comments

  1. I don’t think this is for me – I don’t like books that take too long to wrap things up at the end.

  2. I don’t think this is for me – I don’t like books that take too long to wrap things up at the end.

  3. The tourism aspect sounds interesting, but overall, it sounds like the execution was not that great in the rest of the book. I am not sure why, but these types of books don’t really appeal to me, so I am not really sure if I would read it. I am sorry that you were disappointed with it and that it took too long to wrap up.

  4. The tourism aspect sounds interesting, but overall, it sounds like the execution was not that great in the rest of the book. I am not sure why, but these types of books don’t really appeal to me, so I am not really sure if I would read it. I am sorry that you were disappointed with it and that it took too long to wrap up.

  5. I like the central debate but I think the excess length and the less than likable characters might turn me off.

  6. I like the central debate but I think the excess length and the less than likable characters might turn me off.

  7. I definitely see what you mean about Francesca — she was annoying from beginning to end. I really loved I Remember You overall, though, and wasn’t too bothered by Adam’s behavior! I figured he was trying to work through his feelings for Tess/his mom/etc. Definitely see where you’re coming from, though!

  8. I definitely see what you mean about Francesca — she was annoying from beginning to end. I really loved I Remember You overall, though, and wasn’t too bothered by Adam’s behavior! I figured he was trying to work through his feelings for Tess/his mom/etc. Definitely see where you’re coming from, though!

  9. When it drags you feel the author is just buying time!!! Thanks for an honest review.

  10. When it drags you feel the author is just buying time!!! Thanks for an honest review.

  11. Sorry this ended up being disappointing for you. But so good of your to try the author again.

  12. Sorry this ended up being disappointing for you. But so good of your to try the author again.

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy:  I welcome comments and read each one I receive. If your comment needs a response, I will provide it in a timely manner, as I read every comment I receive. Please keep your comments civil and polite! I reserve the right to delete any comments that are rude or inappropriate. Because of spam, I have to moderate comments on old posts. Please be patient - I will approve your comment quickly.

Before the tag in the Genesis footer: !-- Quantcast Tag -->