Book Review: Madras on Rainy Days – Samina Ali [TSS]

Title: Madras on Rainy Days
Author: Samina Ali
ISBN: 9780312423308
Pages: 309
Release Date: January 15, 2004
Publisher: Picador
Genre: Literary Fiction, Multicultural Fiction
Source: Personal Copy
Rating: 4.5 out of 5

Summary:

Layla, a young Muslim-American woman, has returned to her family’s home in Hyderabad, India for an arranged marriage.  Though she has agreed to the marriage, she has a secret – she lost her virginity before leaving the United States and became pregnant.  Though she terminated the pregnancy, she is still suffering from its aftereffects while trying to hide her condition from those around her.

Review:

Madras on Rainy Days was an incredibly contemplative book about life for a young Muslim woman living in modern-day India.  Though Layla has spent much of her life in the United States, she has spent an equal time in India and thus is torn between two worlds.  She is denied many of the freedoms of a young American woman by her parents, who fear that, given the chance, she will act out and do things unbecoming to a Muslim woman.  However, Layla finds a way to do the one thing they fear most – to lose her virginity to an American man.

As Layla contemplates her situation, she goes through the motions preparing for her marriage.  In this way, it’s a very quiet novel.  What will happen if her secret is discovered?  Will her husband reject her?  While Layla is dreading her marriage, at the same time, it’s what she wants. 

This novel also deals with many issues facing India and the Muslim community today.  Cultural and religious violence is an ever present threat, hovering just behind the story, threatening to make its presence known at any time.  Divorce in the Muslim community and what it means for a man and a woman going through it, is also discussed.  Of course, through Layla’s situation, the purity of a young woman going into marriage for Muslims is also an important topic.  It’s difficult to discuss these issues in a review without revealing the twists and turns the story takes, so I’ll just leave it at that.  Ali does not shy away from difficult topics, but the book never becomes hard to read or heavy.

Looking through online reviews, I was surprised to find middling to negative reviews of this book, which I found eye opening and very interesting.  After reading their content, I have to disagree with them.  The jist of these reviews said that Ali was playing on cultural stereotypes and didn’t know what she was talking about with Madras on Rainy Days.  To a certain extent, that’s probably true – Layla’s story is a dramatic one, and there are definitely hills and valleys on her journey.  However, I don’t believe that means this story is inaccurate or isn’t worth reading.  It’s worth keeping in mind for this novel, or for any multicultural book, that you can’t make generalizations from one story.  A book like this isn’t meant to make people think that all Muslim people in India act like this.  It’s meant to tell a story and open people’s eyes to another possibility, and I think it does that incredibly well.

I thought Madras on Rainy Days was an excellent read, easier than a lot of the cultural literary fiction out there.  Ali crafts a sympathetic main character who makes mistakes along the way, but you can’t help but feel for the situations she finds herself in.  I’m sad that this is Samina Ali’s only book, as I’d love to read more of her work.

Affiliate Links:

Buy this book from Powell’s Books
Buy this book from Amazon.com

Comments

  1. Oh wow, this book sounds really good! And I love the cover.

  2. Oh wow, this book sounds really good! And I love the cover.

  3. Sounds like a wonderful novel. I’ve added it to my TBR list. Thanks!

  4. Sounds like a wonderful novel. I’ve added it to my TBR list. Thanks!

  5. This sounds like a book I would like, but I have to wonder why they made the cover like that – it’s hard to figure out the name of the book.

  6. This sounds like a book I would like, but I have to wonder why they made the cover like that – it’s hard to figure out the name of the book.

  7. This sounds so good; I am adding it to my TBR list

  8. This sounds so good; I am adding it to my TBR list

  9. This is a new author as well as book for me. I love the storyline as its so contemporary. Now to try to track it down!

  10. This is a new author as well as book for me. I love the storyline as its so contemporary. Now to try to track it down!

  11. The situation that this book tackles fascinates me, and I think it would make for a great read. I also think the negative reviews on it are interesting, and if anything, they make me even more interested in reading the book and seeing which camp I fall into. Thanks for sharing this with us. This one is going on my list!

  12. The situation that this book tackles fascinates me, and I think it would make for a great read. I also think the negative reviews on it are interesting, and if anything, they make me even more interested in reading the book and seeing which camp I fall into. Thanks for sharing this with us. This one is going on my list!

  13. I’m sure this is a book that has subject matter that might tread on some people’s toes. But I think each author is allowed to explore her feelings and imagination.

    I just can’t get over that cover.

  14. I’m sure this is a book that has subject matter that might tread on some people’s toes. But I think each author is allowed to explore her feelings and imagination.

    I just can’t get over that cover.

  15. I do not like the cover, but the book sounds good. I will keep this in mind.

  16. I do not like the cover, but the book sounds good. I will keep this in mind.

  17. It’s funny because I never really noticed the cover! I knew I wanted to read it before I knew what the cover looked like, so when I got it, I didn’t even really look. But you guys are right, the cover is really distracting.

  18. It’s funny because I never really noticed the cover! I knew I wanted to read it before I knew what the cover looked like, so when I got it, I didn’t even really look. But you guys are right, the cover is really distracting.

  19. Madras On Rainy Days is an excellant read . I am 60 and a native of Madras . The title attracted me to buy the novel. Then only I came to know about the author Ms Samina Ali. This book is an eye opener on human relations.

    I would love to read more of her works. Its almost 6 years over and wish her best wishes to give us more and more good works.

  20. Madras On Rainy Days is an excellant read . I am 60 and a native of Madras . The title attracted me to buy the novel. Then only I came to know about the author Ms Samina Ali. This book is an eye opener on human relations.

    I would love to read more of her works. Its almost 6 years over and wish her best wishes to give us more and more good works.

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy:  I welcome comments and read each one I receive. If your comment needs a response, I will provide it in a timely manner, as I read every comment I receive. Please keep your comments civil and polite! I reserve the right to delete any comments that are rude or inappropriate. Because of spam, I have to moderate comments on old posts. Please be patient - I will approve your comment quickly.

Before the tag in the Genesis footer: !-- Quantcast Tag -->