Book Review: Her Sister’s Shadow – Katharine Britton

Title: Her Sister’s Shadow
Author: Katharine Britton
ISBN: 9780425241745
Pages: 352
Release Date: June 7, 2011
Publisher: Berkley
Genre: Women’s Fiction
Source: Publisher
Rating: 3.5 out of 5

Summary:

When Lilli Niles receives word that her estranged sister’s husband has passed away, she reluctantly returns to her family home in Massachusetts.  There’s a good reason that Lilli has stayed away for so long, and going back home brings back painful memories of the summer that changed her and Bea’s relationship forever.

Review:

Her Sister’s Shadow is a novel about love and loss told in two different time frames – the present day, and a fateful summer years ago when Lilli was a teenager in love for the first time.  At the beginning, the time shifts can seem a bit cumbersome because the story takes some time to develop.  I kept waiting for the book to come back to the present, so I could get to know Lilli better and really understand who she is.  Once the story really got going, though, I enjoyed both the time periods and thought the shifting was handled well.

Lilli was a sympathetic character, though frustrating at times, especially as a teenager.  She’s clearly in the throes of adolescence, and while her moodiness is realistic, it’s not always the most pleasant trait in a character you’re supposed to feel for.  Despite that, she was well fleshed out and fully realized.  I appreciated how Lilli really came to life in front of me as I was reading.

Though I enjoyed Her Sister’s Shadow overall, I did have a major issue with it, and it’s difficult to discuss because it came at the end.  Basically, the reader knows from the beginning that there is a secret, a reason Lilli left her home and never looked back.  There’s a very good explanation for why Lilli has barely maintained a relationship with Bea, and of course, it all becomes clear at the end of the book.  My problem was, while what Lilli went through was extremely difficult (and a bit predictable), I didn’t see any of it as being Bea’s fault.  Of course Lilli would want to leave the place that held such painful memories, but Lilli blamed everything on Bea, and that seemed completely unjustified to me.

Still, Her Sister’s Shadow is an interesting look at the difficult relationship among sisters.  These relationships are full of resentment and petty injustices, but also of love and trust and hope.  Britton captures that dynamic very well in Her Sister’s Shadow, and anyone interested in reading about it should consider picking up this book.

Affiliate Links:

Buy this book from Powell’s Books
Buy this book from Amazon.com
Buy this book from your local Indiebound bookstore

Comments

  1. I have a feeling that this would not be a good match for me. I think your major issue would be a killer for me.

  2. I have a feeling that this would not be a good match for me. I think your major issue would be a killer for me.

  3. I can see where you’d have an issue with that. However, I do think there are some self-absorbed people who blame everything that’s wrong in their lives on someone else, so that might be realistic for some people.

  4. I can see where you’d have an issue with that. However, I do think there are some self-absorbed people who blame everything that’s wrong in their lives on someone else, so that might be realistic for some people.

  5. I would probably feel the same way that you did regarding the blaming in the end, and can imagine that it might ruin the story for me. I am sort of trying to guess what happened, and coming up with some plausible ideas, but I probably won’t read the book to find out if I am right about them! I do agree with Kathy though, that there are just some people who have a sort of victim mentality and blame a lot of their problems on others instead of themselves, or more appropriately, where blame is due. Very thought-provoking review today, Swapna!

  6. I would probably feel the same way that you did regarding the blaming in the end, and can imagine that it might ruin the story for me. I am sort of trying to guess what happened, and coming up with some plausible ideas, but I probably won’t read the book to find out if I am right about them! I do agree with Kathy though, that there are just some people who have a sort of victim mentality and blame a lot of their problems on others instead of themselves, or more appropriately, where blame is due. Very thought-provoking review today, Swapna!

  7. I’m sure your reaction would be my reaction. I don’t really want to go all the way through the process of discovering this trauma and not feel it was resolved reasonably.

  8. I’m sure your reaction would be my reaction. I don’t really want to go all the way through the process of discovering this trauma and not feel it was resolved reasonably.

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy:  I welcome comments and read each one I receive. If your comment needs a response, I will provide it in a timely manner, as I read every comment I receive. Please keep your comments civil and polite! I reserve the right to delete any comments that are rude or inappropriate. Because of spam, I have to moderate comments on old posts. Please be patient - I will approve your comment quickly.

Before the tag in the Genesis footer: !-- Quantcast Tag -->