Book Review: Another Piece of My Heart – Jane Green

Title: Another Piece of My Heart
Author: Jane Green
ISBN: 9780312591823
Pages: 400
Release Date: March 13, 2012
Publisher: St. Martin’s Press
Genre: Women’s Fiction
Source: Big Honcho Media/SheKnows Book Club
Rating: 4 out of 5

Summary:

At thirty-seven, Andi was starting to lose faith that she’d ever find the perfect man, that is, until she met Ethan.  But Ethan’s situation was more complicated than she expected – he was divorced, with an alcoholic ex-wife, and two daughters.  Now, as a stepmother, Andi tries to be the best mom she can to these two girls.  The younger, Sophia, is full of love and Andi adores her, but she has trouble with Emily.  Emily seems to insist on competing with Andi for her father’s love, and as a teenager, she makes life very difficult.  Andi must decide whether she can handle Emily’s antics, or whether she’d be better off alone.

Review:

Okay, I’ll admit it.  When I first heard about the premise of Another Piece of My Heart, I was skeptical.  I figured it would be another “saintly stepmother who is a doormat lets evil teenage girl walk all over her” plotline and I wasn’t thrilled about the idea.  But because it’s Jane Green, and I love and admire her work, I knew I had to read it.  And I should have had more faith – Jane Green is an exceptional author, and she took this seemingly conventional storyline and upended it completely.

Andi is really an amazing character in Another Piece of My Heart.  The thing I appreciated about her most?  She stood up for herself.  While she did try to understand where Emily was coming from, she understood that Emily was selfish and manipulative and did her best to correct that behavior.  Unfortunately, Ethan wasn’t as receptive as one might hope, but I loved that she took a stand.  It’s easy to understand why Andi is at the end of her rope; Emily’s behavior is simply atrocious, and Andi wonders whether she can cope.  Andi’s a sympathetic character, the type you’d want as a friend, but she’s human.  She lashes out and makes mistakes; I loved how layered Green made Andi.

But the author didn’t stop with Andi.  Emily, evil, manipulative Emily, has a voice in this novel too, and that saved her from being a complete caricature of a teenage girl.  After witnessing her awful behavior and really feeling for Andi, the reader gets inside Emily’s head.  They begin to understand her motives and desires, to see how deep her insecurities run.  It’s clear she’s very immature and has a lot to learn, but in some ways, she’s just a scared girl.  The reader can’t hate her after seeing that.

It would be so easy to paint each of the characters in Another Piece of My Heart into a box, yet Jane Green doesn’t allow the character to do that.  The novel has a few predictable twists, but it’s still a quick, snappy read that readers will devour.  This is a book I read in one sitting because I had to know what happened; fans of Greens won’t be disappointed.  If you’re looking for a breezy book club pick that still deals with serious issues, look no further than Another Piece of My Heart.

Other books by Jane Green:

The Beach House – Jane Green
Dune Road – Jane Green
Promises to Keep – Jane Green’

Affiliate Links:

Buy this book from Powell’s Books
Buy this book from Amazon.com
Buy this book from your local Indiebound bookstore

Comments

  1. It sounded really good in Kathy’s review too. I’ve not read any Jane Green but it sounds like I’m missing out. Then there is the ear worm that you get with Janis Joplin…

  2. It sounded really good in Kathy’s review too. I’ve not read any Jane Green but it sounds like I’m missing out. Then there is the ear worm that you get with Janis Joplin…

  3. This one is on my wishlist. I’m really glad that you enjoyed it as well. I haven’t read any Jane Green, but I think I’ll need to change this soon.

  4. This one is on my wishlist. I’m really glad that you enjoyed it as well. I haven’t read any Jane Green, but I think I’ll need to change this soon.

  5. I have this one on audio and am definitely looking forward to reading it! Green writes very layered, sympathetic female characters — I dig it.

  6. I have this one on audio and am definitely looking forward to reading it! Green writes very layered, sympathetic female characters — I dig it.

  7. I feel like I might really like this one, and it sort of reminds me a bit of some of the issues that were present in Carry the One. It does sound like Green does an amazing job of making her characters realistic and multi-layered, and I am betting that this is a book that I would enjoy. Thanks for sharing your perspective on it with us. I enjoyed reading your thoughts and am off to look for this one!

  8. I feel like I might really like this one, and it sort of reminds me a bit of some of the issues that were present in Carry the One. It does sound like Green does an amazing job of making her characters realistic and multi-layered, and I am betting that this is a book that I would enjoy. Thanks for sharing your perspective on it with us. I enjoyed reading your thoughts and am off to look for this one!

  9. I have this on my shelf and really need to read it. I’ve heard nothing but good things!

  10. I have this on my shelf and really need to read it. I’ve heard nothing but good things!

  11. This was my first experience with Green’s work and I really liked it.

  12. This was my first experience with Green’s work and I really liked it.

  13. I haven’t quite got to this yet, but I hope I enjoy it as well. 😉

  14. I haven’t quite got to this yet, but I hope I enjoy it as well. 😉

  15. Hi, I’m from Panama in Central America and I’m a big fan of blogger and I have my own blog, Apasionados por los libros of course in spanish.
    This is the first time I visit your blog and it’s beautiful, all the interface and desing is perfect. And I fall in love with your way to write these reviews.
    I hope read this book ASAP!

  16. Hi, I’m from Panama in Central America and I’m a big fan of blogger and I have my own blog, Apasionados por los libros of course in spanish.
    This is the first time I visit your blog and it’s beautiful, all the interface and desing is perfect. And I fall in love with your way to write these reviews.
    I hope read this book ASAP!

  17. I just started this book on audio the other day – I’m glad to see that you liked it!

  18. I just started this book on audio the other day – I’m glad to see that you liked it!

  19. I enjoyed it and it’s definitely one of her better books in recent years. Promises to Keep was very good as well.

    I liked Andi but didn’t always think she was really trying. Emily needed therapy. She wouldn’t have worked through those issues on her own, in my opinion.

  20. I enjoyed it and it’s definitely one of her better books in recent years. Promises to Keep was very good as well.

    I liked Andi but didn’t always think she was really trying. Emily needed therapy. She wouldn’t have worked through those issues on her own, in my opinion.

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy:  I welcome comments and read each one I receive. If your comment needs a response, I will provide it in a timely manner, as I read every comment I receive. Please keep your comments civil and polite! I reserve the right to delete any comments that are rude or inappropriate. Because of spam, I have to moderate comments on old posts. Please be patient - I will approve your comment quickly.

Before the tag in the Genesis footer: !-- Quantcast Tag -->