Book Review: As I Wake – Elizabeth Scott

Title: As I Wake
Author: Elizabeth Scott
ISBN: 9780525422099
Pages: 224
Release Date: September 15, 2011
Publisher: Dutton Juvenile
Genre: Teen/YA
Source: Personal Copy
Rating: 3 out of 5

Summary:

When teenager Ava wakes up in the hospital, she can’t remember anything about where she came from.  She doesn’t even remember her own name.  As she struggles to rebuild her life with her mom and her friends at school, she begins to have visions, dreams that speak to a very different life than the one she’s living now.  Ava must decide what is real and what is not, as she begins to suspect that those around her are lying to her.

Review:

When I first heard the plot for As I Wake, it reminded me of the trend that is going through women’s fiction right now – the amnesia, become a better-version-of-yourself plotline.  However, after the first few pages of this book, it became clear very quickly that As I Wake was something completely different.  Ava’s visions aren’t of having a different boyfriend or living in a different house.  Instead, they’re of an entirely different world, a sort of dystopian society, which makes things incredibly confusing for Ava.

Unfortunately, that also makes the situation incredibly complex for readers of As I Wake.  This is a book I muddled through, unsure of what was happening or where the novel was going.  While I appreciated the originality, every page generated more questions, with virtually no answers.  It’s unclear what the alternate reality (for lack of a better term) is, and Scott provides few answers as the novel progresses.  The vagueness that surrounds the plot and backstory really detracted from the experience.

Ava also wasn’t the most sympathetic character.  It’s not that she wasn’t likeable, but more that she really didn’t have a personality.  She spends the novel trying to figure things out her history, rather than who she was as a person.  That means that, while her story is interesting, readers won’t feel much connection to her as she navigates through what her life appears to be.

Overall, As I Wake just didn’t work for me.  I understood what Scott was trying to do, and loved the fact that she used the amnesia storyline in a very original and creative way, but the book was a difficult read.  The real disappointment for me was that the storyline never comes together in a way that makes sense, and thus I was left wanting.  While I am a big fan of Elizabeth Scott, this was by no means my favorite work of hers, though I do look forward to her next book.

Other books by Elizabeth Scott:

Love You, Hate You, Miss You – Elizabeth Scott
Living Dead Girl – Elizabeth Scott
Something, Maybe – Elizabeth Scott
Between Here and Forever – Elizabeth Scott
The Unwritten Rule – Elizabeth Scott

Affiliate Links:

Buy this book from Powell’s Books
Buy this book from Amazon.com
Buy this book from your local Indiebound bookstore

Comments

  1. It’s always a shame when an author has a really great, unique idea but can’t seem to pull it together in the end. If there is one thing that is frustrating as a reader, it’s being presented with a mystery and never shown the solution (I’m looking at you Tana French!) Have you read Before I Go to Sleep? I haven’t read many books with amnesia in it, but I thought this one was really interesting (and I couldn’t put it down).

  2. It’s always a shame when an author has a really great, unique idea but can’t seem to pull it together in the end. If there is one thing that is frustrating as a reader, it’s being presented with a mystery and never shown the solution (I’m looking at you Tana French!) Have you read Before I Go to Sleep? I haven’t read many books with amnesia in it, but I thought this one was really interesting (and I couldn’t put it down).

  3. That’s a bummer the ending didn’t provide enough answers. That would really annoy me. I’ve read one book by Scott and really liked it, and I’m hoping to check out more, but I suppose I should give a pass on this one. Love the cover though!!

    -Lauren

  4. That’s a bummer the ending didn’t provide enough answers. That would really annoy me. I’ve read one book by Scott and really liked it, and I’m hoping to check out more, but I suppose I should give a pass on this one. Love the cover though!!

    -Lauren

  5. Yeah, this wasn’t my favorite Scott either although I did really appreciate the originality. I love when authors try new things instead of just writing essentially the same story over and over again.

  6. Yeah, this wasn’t my favorite Scott either although I did really appreciate the originality. I love when authors try new things instead of just writing essentially the same story over and over again.

  7. If you muddled you way through, confused and wanting, I can only imagine how complex and strange this book would have been for me! It does sound like the author started off in a great direction with the plot, but perhaps she couldn’t quite harness it all successfully. I’m afraid I am going to give this one a pass.

  8. If you muddled you way through, confused and wanting, I can only imagine how complex and strange this book would have been for me! It does sound like the author started off in a great direction with the plot, but perhaps she couldn’t quite harness it all successfully. I’m afraid I am going to give this one a pass.

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy:  I welcome comments and read each one I receive. If your comment needs a response, I will provide it in a timely manner, as I read every comment I receive. Please keep your comments civil and polite! I reserve the right to delete any comments that are rude or inappropriate. Because of spam, I have to moderate comments on old posts. Please be patient - I will approve your comment quickly.

Before the tag in the Genesis footer: !-- Quantcast Tag -->