Book Review: The Prisoner of Heaven – Carlos Ruiz Zafon [TSS]

Title: The Prisoner of Heaven
Author: Carlos Ruiz Zafon
ISBN: 9780062206282
Pages: 288
Release Date: July 10, 2012
Publisher: Harper
Genre: Literary Fiction
Source: Publisher
Rating: 3.5 out of 5

Summary:

The year is 1957, and it’s Christmas in Barcelona. Daniel Sempere is thrilled that his old friend Fermin Romero de Torres is going to be wed. But when a mysterious stranger from Fermin’s past visits Daniel in his family’s bookstore, Fermin must come clean about secrets he’s been hiding for years.

Review:

The Shadow of the Wind and The Angel’s Game were the first two novels in Zafon’s trilogy about the Cemetery of Forgotten Books, and now he completes it with The Prisoner of Heaven. Indeed, readers of those two books will recognize the main characters of this one, as they were the major characters.

Unlike those first two books, though, The Prisoner of Heaven will make little sense if readers haven’t consumed the first two books in the trilogy. It very much seems to be written for fans of The Cemetery of Forgotten Books, rather than new readers. If you’re rusty on what happened in the first two books, you’d do well to review them before picking up this one, as you may not understand everything that happens in it if you don’t.

While The Prisoner of Heaven is interesting and easy to read, it unfortunately lacks much of the magic that swept readers away in previous books. The language isn’t quite as lush or poetic, and the descriptions don’t reach the level of beauty that readers have come to expect from Zafon. As Zafon’s prose is a huge part of the reason I enjoy his novels so much, I found this to be disappointing.

Additionally, The Prisoner of Heaven lacks the mysterious nature of the first two books. It’s relatively straightforward, with few jaw dropping revelations or shocking twists. It also doesn’t have the sense of foreboding, that darkness which Zafon writes so well. The novel is a little lighter, but that also makes it easier to read. It’s a book you can zip through, which might delight readers who were disappointed in the heaviness and difficulty of The Angel’s Game.

If you’ve read the first two novels about The Cemetery of Forgotten Books, reading The Prisoner of Heaven is a real no-brainer. Zafon wraps up his trilogy well, so that readers won’t be left wondering about the fate of characters. But if you haven’t sampled Zafon’s work before, starting with The Shadow of the Wind is highly recommended. Now that Zafon has wrapped up this trilogy, it will be interesting to see what he does next.

EDIT: I have been told by multiple readers in the comments that the series is actually a quartet, and not a trilogy as Zafon originally planned. My opinions on the book are a bit different knowing there is more to come, but I stand by my thoughts here.

Other books by Carlos Ruiz Zafon:

The Angel’s Game
The Prince of Mist

Affiliate Links:

Buy this book from Powell’s Books
Buy this book from Amazon.com
Buy this book from your local Indiebound bookstore

Comments

  1. I’ve only read The Shadow of the Wind so I may get to this book eventually.

  2. I’ve only read The Shadow of the Wind so I may get to this book eventually.

  3. If I’m not mistaken, the series is actually a quartet and not a trilogy, with one more book still to go…

  4. If I’m not mistaken, the series is actually a quartet and not a trilogy, with one more book still to go…

  5. The Shadow of The Wind. Did love it
    Must read The Angels Game..
    Then the other’s

  6. The Shadow of The Wind. Did love it
    Must read The Angels Game..
    Then the other’s

  7. I actually don’t think this is the wrap-up novel. I believe it’s a series of four books, not three. I did love the Cemetery of Forgotten Books, but I don’t think I remember enough of The Shadow of the Wind to pick up the story right where it took off- I LOVED Fermin, though!

  8. I actually don’t think this is the wrap-up novel. I believe it’s a series of four books, not three. I did love the Cemetery of Forgotten Books, but I don’t think I remember enough of The Shadow of the Wind to pick up the story right where it took off- I LOVED Fermin, though!

  9. On the description at Amazon he says he intends it to be 4 books. I LOVED Shadow of the Wind and I’m reading The Angel’s Game right now. I’m sad to hear this one doesn’t quite live up to expectations, but I’ll be reading it anyway! Thanks for the review!

  10. On the description at Amazon he says he intends it to be 4 books. I LOVED Shadow of the Wind and I’m reading The Angel’s Game right now. I’m sad to hear this one doesn’t quite live up to expectations, but I’ll be reading it anyway! Thanks for the review!

  11. It’s definitely a series of 4 books and I felt like this one sets it up beautifully for the final one. It’s a bummer it didn’t work better for you.

  12. It’s definitely a series of 4 books and I felt like this one sets it up beautifully for the final one. It’s a bummer it didn’t work better for you.

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy:  I welcome comments and read each one I receive. If your comment needs a response, I will provide it in a timely manner, as I read every comment I receive. Please keep your comments civil and polite! I reserve the right to delete any comments that are rude or inappropriate. Because of spam, I have to moderate comments on old posts. Please be patient - I will approve your comment quickly.

Before the tag in the Genesis footer: !-- Quantcast Tag -->